AI vs English Teachers: Do You Still Need Us?
2026-11-08 25 min
Description & Show Notes
AI vs English Teachers: Can ChatGPT replace human language learning?
Can ChatGPT and AI language-learning apps really help you become fluent in English? Or is there something AI simply can't replace?
In this episode of 3 English Experts, Dave, Rebecca and Birgit explore the future of AI in language learning, from practising English with AI chatbots to the power of real conversations, human connection and motivation.
Discover the benefits, frustrations and limitations of learning English with AI, plus our Golden Nuggets: 3 practical tips to get more out of your English conversation groups.
AI or human teachers – who wins? Listen now and decide for yourself
Better English. Brighter Conversations.
- 0:27: Will AI replace language teachers?
- 1:05: Learning Dutch with AI: Why speaking practice wasn't enough
- 3:59: Will future generations prefer AI teachers?
- 5:46: Why personality and human connection matter
- 8:13: Staying curious and avoiding overreliance on AI
- 10:23: Overcoming the fear of speaking English with AI
- 11:05: Motivation and the importance of positive relationships
- 12:14: How to write better AI prompts for language learning
- 15:35: Using AI for ideas and learning materials
- 16:35: Why learning is an emotional experience
- 18:08: The human touch and freedom to choose
- 20:09: Golden Nuggets: How to make the most of English conversation groups
- 20:42: Prepare, accept feedback and practise active listening
- 23:09: Next episode: Improve your vocabulary with synonyms
Would you like to work with us?
Join our Conversation Club and activate your English with one of us and other like-minded people. Just €199 for 10 (60 mins sessions).
Would you like a free trial?
1. Go to the booking form.
2. Choose a date you want.
3. Select ONE session (normally priced at 25 euro).
4. Add in the promo code: FREESESSION26 at the checkout.
Rebecca: www.rebeccadeacon.com
Birgit: https://birgitkasimirski.de
- 0:27: Wird KI Sprachlehrer ersetzen?
- 1:05: Niederländischlernen mit KI: Warum Sprechübungen allein nicht ausreichen
- 3:59: Werden zukünftige Generationen KI-Lehrer bevorzugen?
- 5:46: Warum Persönlichkeit und menschlicher Kontakt wichtig sind
- 8:13: Neugierig bleiben und sich nicht zu sehr auf KI verlassen
- 10:23: Mit KI die Angst vor dem Englischsprechen überwinden
- 11:05: Motivation und die Bedeutung positiver Beziehungen
- 12:14: Bessere KI-Prompts fürs Sprachenlernen formulieren
- 15:35: KI für Ideen und Lernmaterialien nutzen
- 16:35: Warum Lernen eine emotionale Erfahrung ist
- 18:08: Der persönliche Kontakt und die Freiheit, selbst zu entscheiden
- 20:09: Golden Nuggets: Das Beste aus englischen Konversationsgruppen herausholen
- 20:42: Gut vorbereiten, Feedback annehmen und aktiv zuhören
- 23:09: Vorschau: Den Wortschatz mit Synonymen erweitern
Transcript
(Transcribed by TurboScribe. Go Unlimited to remove this message.) Hi, welcome to the 3 English Experts.
I'm Dave, I'm Rebecca and I'm Birgit and welcome to this episode.
3 English Experts is your English podcast to help you speak better English and create a positive and happy mindset for your English learning journey.
Welcome back everybody.
Welcome to this episode.
Today we're going to talk about AI.
I know everybody's always talking about AI at the moment, but it is an interesting topic.
And like most things, language learning has been massively affected by AI, whether it's teaching, learning.
So today we're going to talk about, we often get asked, oh, will we need teachers in the future because AI is going to do everything?
The question is, will learners want that?
You know, will learners really want to learn just with AI or will they still want to have a teacher?
Why?
Why not?
Positives and negatives.
So we're going to talk about things that you can use it for that are quite helpful, useful in our experience and also look at the flip side as well.
So Birgit is going to kick off and tell us a bit about her Dutch adventure.
Birgit?
Hello everybody.
Yes.
Once more, my Dutch adventure.
Yes, AI, a fascinating topic and of course we do need to look into it and we do use it.
And of course I hear that also what Rebecca just said, people say to me, okay, your job will be gone soon or people will not book you.
But up to today, I've always felt like, no, I'm still needed out there.
And my own experience with Dutch was that of course I tried out apps, I did online learnings and I tried to advance.
And at one stage, some stage I discovered this.
I think we talked about this app TalkPal by ChatGPT, so it's like an avatar.
There's also Laura, now another app only focusing on English.
And I tried it out and I thought, oh, that's fantastic.
So I spoke to the app in the car, I pressed play so I could talk and it would respond to me and it would transcript and it will show me the mistakes and all that.
And I thought, oh, that's brilliant.
So you can talk to a person without having a real person there.
So and I did that for about a few months, whereas I don't do that every day.
But then at some point, I thought, I got really bored and I thought, no, that's not it.
It didn't feel like a real conversation.
Of course, Emma, the avatar was always responding and I could talk, but my motivation wasn't there.
And when I felt like, do I want to talk to this machine again?
She's always going to ask me, where are you going?
Oh, that's fascinating.
What are you doing next?
We're in Dutch, obviously.
And I was kind of improving.
That wasn't too bad, but that was not it.
So I came to a point where I really felt, no, let's try a group session.
So I booked myself into a session, a group session of Dutch learners.
And there I met wonderful people from New Zealand, a lady from Scotland.
And that felt so much different.
And that's what I'm telling people now, that it does make a difference.
So to a certain, up to a certain point, I think AI really helps us.
And I use it, of course, and it makes my life a lot easier and so much faster when I need ideas.
So I can get a script easily, but it's only script for me.
So that's like a first draft.
For me at the moment, I think I still need to work myself with somebody on ideas or on a language.
Dave.
Yeah.
What do you think?
What do you think?
What's your experience?
I think Dave has something, his own thoughts about that.
Yeah.
Hello, everyone.
Yes.
Thank you.
I mean, I'm a big tech fan.
I love working with tech and I try and do as much or test as much as I can out with AI.
My go-to one is Charlie or aka ChatGPT.
But of course, there's also Claude and all the other things.
I'm in a situation where I think it can be sort of dangerous for us English teachers going forward, but I think it will also be a generational thing.
My son is now 15 and I know that he likes tech and he's into tech.
I haven't asked him, but I could imagine that he would be okay working, like you said, Birgit, with an avatar or something like this.
But I think maybe after that, the generation after that, I think that's where there maybe is this possibility of them working just with avatars and maybe then generally in society, which is getting a bit deep here and probably very controversial, as to whether there will be really teachers in the classroom at school.
I'm kind of curious where that will go, not just for English, but also for other languages of the subjects at school.
I think in the short term, especially, for example, in group sessions, because that's what you mentioned, Birgit, going to a group session with other people, there won't be a big difference because people will want to go be with other people.
But as the generations go on, I could well imagine that maybe my son's generation, the one after that, I think it could then become normal just to have even a group session with an avatar leading it.
I'm curious what you guys think about that one, but I could imagine that's the way it's going.
Hello, everybody.
I have to say something.
Rebecca.
It's like a red rag to a bull here.
I'm not sure.
I do agree with you, I think from a practicality and a technology point of view and all of that and the generations they're going to grow up with this and they're going to be so used to it.
I do think isn't it all going to get very, very boring?
Because we said this before, like people work with us not just because of our expertise and our knowledge.
They also work with us because of our personalities.
Why do people listen to us on this podcast?
As someone said to me a while ago, oh, you know, you can create a podcast now and all you have to do is speak a few sentences so it can copy your voice, tell it what you want to talk about and it will create the whole script and it will record it all and you don't need to do anything.
And I just said, well, why would I want to do that?
And they were like, oh, well, because it saves you time, but it would be so boring and it wouldn't be me.
And I also feel like if I can't be bothered to spend the time recording this podcast, why should anybody be bothered to listen to me if I'm just splurging out nonsense that's being created by Jack G.B.T.? For me, it's the boredom factor.
It's like what makes life interesting is people and personality.
And I know AI tries to have personality and it tries to be funny and it tries to be your friend, but it's just so plain vanilla.
It's just got no, because it'll never say anything really bad because it's not allowed to do that.
And it'll never sort of, yeah, it's just too boring.
And I just think when I think about when people say or why they work with me, for example, they'll go, yeah, she's really experienced and she speaks different languages, but they'll also say we always have fun.
We enjoy spending time with her.
And that's the other thing is like, how are you going to motivate people to come to a class that's just, it might be technically and have all the right info and grammar and all the rest of it, but it's just boring.
I honestly think generations going on at some point, there will be a backlash because people just say, I'm just, it's too bland.
Bland is for me, the word for AI, it's bland and there's no seasoning.
It's like a sauce with no salt and pepper.
It's bland.
And I think it's like vinyl.
Everyone said, oh, no, vinyl's dead.
No one's going to listen to music on vinyl.
Massive return of vinyl because everyone realized, oh, it actually sounds pretty good.
There is a reason why people buy vinyl.
And it's the same thing.
I just find it.
It's like having ice cream and all you eat is vanilla.
Why would you eat a massive bowl of vanilla when you can have vanilla, chocolate, strawberry and pistachio?
You just wouldn't do it, would you?
You know, and I'm so glad when I look at my children as a parent, I feel the responsibility to tell them, then please stay interested, stay curious.
I see my children and they enjoy being part of groups and spend time with their people.
And hopefully and I think the responsibility also is here to own that, to take responsibility and say, OK, that's important.
And that's what's the differentiation between AI and us.
Hopefully it will be like that.
And another point is not become too lazy.
I mean, we talked about that before.
We need to mention that literacy has gone down.
And we should stay curious and we shouldn't believe everything.
So as journalists, we can't believe everything we should check.
We shouldn't really sit down and say, OK, there's somebody who does everything for us.
That would be too lazy and too easy.
We know in life the easy way is never the best one, is it?
Absolutely.
So I completely agree with that.
I totally agree with you as well, in the sense of we're going to have to find a way how to deal with it.
And who's going to do that?
Who's going to provide the guidelines?
Is anyone going to do it?
Are we as parents?
Are we as a society?
I mean, I can totally agree with the backlash that you talk about, Rebecca, that that can very well happen.
There are areas where I think it's already starting to happen, even that some people, maybe our generation is already walking away from AI and say, no, I don't want anything more to do with it.
So I could imagine that will increase.
So I think you're right.
It'll be a lot of it's like every time, isn't it?
Always there's these new trends and there'll be those early adopters.
And then it will sort of go back and then there'll be the tail enders, as we call them.
So the ones at the end who may or may not even entertain the new trend or whatever it is.
And just say, no, that's nothing for me.
At the end of the day, I think we've still got a job to do.
Ladies, that's great.
But we mustn't rest on our laurels.
Oh, that's an interesting phrase.
I just want to talk a bit about like Birgit was saying, she did the Dutch thing and she was really was like, wow, this is really great.
We're not saying it's all bad.
And there are definitely things you could do like that.
I know someone said that talking to AI in English was actually helpful because it took away the shame.
You know, it's a robot so you can make your mistakes and you can speak to it without feeling a bit embarrassed, because after you get people, they're too embarrassed to talk.
So I think that's really positive, especially if you're quite low level and you're just starting out.
I mean, never before were you able to talk into a machine and get it like, yeah, an inverted comma, a real life feedback that wasn't possible.
Yeah.
So that was the first moment I thought, wow.
But then I think then, you know, for me, going back, we talked about this a few weeks ago about motivation.
We know that language learning is a long term thing.
It's not a short term.
It's not a sprint.
It's a marathon.
And I think motivation theory, if you look at motivation theory, one of the things that motivates people is positive relationships, being in a situation, whether it's your teacher, whether it's your parents, whether it's the people you work with, your boss, your friends at school, no matter what it is, positive relationships also motivate us to do things.
Why do you go and play football every week?
Maybe your team loses every week, which can be very demotivating, but you go because you like your friends or you like the trainer or your parents encourage you because it's good.
Do you know what I mean?
Those are the things that motivate us.
And I just don't feel that like an AI teacher could motivate people in the same way and have that connection.
I think, again, it wants to be your body, but it's kind of annoying.
Yeah, I get annoyed.
I did.
I got annoyed.
And you see, last week I was creating my new website and I used it and it did a really good job to set up the basic framework of my website.
And I was like, wow, this is amazing.
And this is one of my other points is if you are using it, prompting how to prompt properly.
So my husband works in IT developing and stuff.
So he would have a very good idea of like how to prompt it properly.
And he always says to me, Rebecca, you're just not talking to it properly.
What are you telling it?
And I'm so annoyed with it.
I mean, he's like, yeah, because it doesn't know what you want.
You have to be more exact.
And I think as trainers, we use it to create materials.
So we use it now.
And it's brilliant at doing that because before we would waste or spend hours or fast creating materials and it would take so much of our time.
So that's a really amazing thing it's done for us is we can create all these materials.
Problem is, if you're a learner and you're creating materials, I can imagine that, for example, if I was doing it for Japanese or something, I'm not good enough to judge.
Is this good materials?
Is it relevant?
Sometimes I've asked it to create an exercise for one of my clients.
And then I look at the sentences and I think they're not quite right or they're too high or they're too low or they're not quite the right topic.
They don't quite fit.
So you have to be quite specific with your prompting.
And that's interesting.
I've never asked it to build myself some exercise for that.
What I do, I haven't.
Yeah.
And it can do it quite well.
But you have to be like, I am level, whatever, B2, I want sentences about this.
And I think that would be my tip.
If you are going to use it, be very specific.
I watched a brilliant video the other day on, I think it was on LinkedIn.
And it was about two people.
There was a guy in a sandwich shop, so a bit like Subway.
And the guy behind the counter was supposed to be AI.
And he was saying to him, right.
And he said, oh, I would like sauce on my sandwich.
So the guy who had put the sauce on top of the sandwich, like on the outside, because he said, yes, on the sandwich.
And he's going, no, no.
Like because you would say, I want sauce on the sandwich and I want mayo on my sandwich.
And so you put it on the top and everything you asked him to do.
He did it literally.
But of course, it was no common sense.
It didn't make any sense.
And the best of it was at the end, you know, like in Subway, you get the long one and they go, would you like me to cut it in half?
They always say that.
Would you like me to cut it in half?
And he said, yes, please.
And he cut it long ways in half instead of in the middle.
So he had these like two really long bits of thin baguette.
And I just thought that's so true because, yeah, it cut it in half.
But whoever would cut a sandwich in half like that?
Nobody, because it just doesn't know because you haven't told it properly.
So prompting is important and it can be very frustrating if it does what you think, well, it thinks it should do.
But it's not quite the right thing.
Dave, have you ever got annoyed by AI?
You seem to be so happy always with your Charlie.
With my Charlie, chat GPT.
Have you ever been mad at Charlie?
Oh, yeah.
Oh, yeah, yeah.
Definitely, definitely.
But I agree with absolutely with Rebecca.
It's about how you prompt it and knowing what to say to it, to be exact, so specific that you get what you want.
But there are times when I'm in a rush and I just put something in and just rubbish comes out.
And I think, oh, Dave, just take a little bit more time, try and construct the prompt a little bit better.
And then usually you get something that is reasonable or better or even better.
But I mean, I think the other thing is it's just a great way just to generally just to get ideas, just creating ideas.
Because definitely it's got the Internet at its core, let's say.
I was going to say fingertips, but it doesn't have fingertips.
It gets everything.
And just sometimes if we'd have written down a for's and against for this topic, let's say, I'm sure we could have got, I don't know, between the three of us, we could have got the same as what maybe an AI would come up with.
But there's always that one or two when you think, oh, yeah, didn't think of that one.
Hopefully we had a certain extra bit, because if not, then we would prove ourselves wrong.
AI could have done it better.
But I think that's the point of it, of our conversation today, isn't it?
People want to learn only with AI in the future.
I don't know.
I cannot see that happening in classrooms with avatars only.
Maybe that's the scenario, but I'm not sure.
Learning is emotional, whether it's languages, whether it's maths, whatever it is.
Everybody who's ever been to school ever will tell you that school time, obviously, when you're younger and you're a teenager and all this kind of stuff.
But learning is an emotional experience.
It's not just this like academic, straightforward computing process.
Our brains don't work like that.
Our brains have emotions linked to learning.
And maybe as in when AI progresses, maybe it will be able to read body language.
It will be able to hear in the tone of voice how someone's feeling when they're speaking.
Maybe it will.
But right now it can't.
And there's so much in teaching that you respond to the people.
I mean, when you stand in front of a class on a group, I know Dave always knows exactly what kind of people he's got sitting there.
I read the people, of course, because I can only help if I understand how someone ticks.
So that's really important.
Yeah, that's really important, I think.
And I think that's the main thing.
And I agree with, actually, at the end of the day with Rebecca, I think there will be a certain amount of backlash at some stage.
But at the same time, I think it's just adding another level to everything.
In the past, as you said, with the vinyl, the CD and whatever else that you have, it'll be the same here.
So there will be the people that swear by the Internet and AI and what have you.
And then there'll be the other end of the scale that says, no, nothing to do with it.
Just leave me alone and I'll do what I normally do and enjoy it that way.
And I definitely need the human.
I think we're OK.
Yeah, it's a bit like dating.
I know people have done online dating.
I haven't done it, but they tell you that you do this online dating and you start messaging and maybe you have a phone call.
And then I met him in real life and I went, oh, no.
And it's like used to be what was it called?
Speed dating where you'd go to a bar and there'd be like 10 people and you'd circulate.
And I just think, can you really just get a connection to someone over through a machine?
It's different seeing someone in real life.
It is different.
It feels different.
Even if it's online, as in videoconferencing, you still see the person and have a different feel about them, I think.
But I think it's similar than dating.
I think because you select earlier.
So I did that a long time ago and then I had that.
I thought, oh, what do you mean?
The people you might not get to talk to normally.
Yeah, you've got the choice, but now you know something about them.
Yeah.
So it's not written on their clothes what they do or what background.
I think that felt somehow similar.
But in the end, the human touch, of course.
So that's interesting, because I suppose you've got this massive selection when you do online dating, like normally day to day.
How many people do you meet?
Exactly.
Different people.
So I'll let you say they don't wear on their shirt.
No, I'm into football.
I like blondes.
And I don't know that's obvious to me.
I thought, oh, that's not bad, actually.
So I meet people with an interesting background for me, but might not be the right one.
Yeah, I think the important thing here is that we have a choice, that we have the freedom to choose.
And that would be one of the most important things, I think.
Absolutely.
Freedom to choose, that we're not forced to use it if we don't want to.
And ultimately, they're all controlled by big tech companies.
You know, who's regulating them?
The governments have now woken up and decided, oh, we need to regulate this and we need to take care of the kids.
And it's all a little bit too late.
You feel like it's already running.
And what are you doing?
So that's the next question.
That's maybe another episode.
We're getting a bit deep now.
That's going to be another episode, yeah.
The Golden Nuggets.
I thought this time we'd have a look at making the most out of your English groups.
I hope that you have the possibility to go to one and to interact with other English learners and also, of course, your trainers.
If you don't, you may want to come to our three English expert conversation groups.
We'd love to see you there and help you work on your English.
So to make the most of it, I think there are three main points we'd like to share with you.
Firstly, is just to be prepared and to be ready for the session, to come in maybe with some ideas, what to talk about.
Maybe some questions that you'd like to ask into the group or ask the trainer or even ask other members of the group.
Another thing that is often I notice, or I think we notice as trainers, is that there are certain members that don't always accept the feedback that they are given.
In the sense of, well, did I really make that mistake?
Really?
Did I?
But most of the time, I think we only mention mistakes in a very gentle way.
We only try to focus on some of maybe the bigger ones that are mid made mistakes and just to accept that you're there to learn and mistakes are the way to get better.
If you make the mistakes, that's the way to find out and to learn and to get better.
And I think finally, it's just that this idea of active listening, which is, again, a very important skill that we need in everyday life.
What do I mean by that?
I mean that you can listen carefully to the other people and also then offer your input as well.
For example, asking the questions to the other people.
And this is as simple sometimes as just knowing the W questions.
I always say to people, come, please, interact with each other, ask each other questions.
And this is often times when people just don't do it.
They have their say about a topic and then they just sort of switch off and don't get involved.
So active listening, listen to each other, ask each other questions.
In a way, the trainer is just there kind of like a moderator who can then listen out, keep the conversation going where necessary.
But at the end of the day, it's all about you guys.
And the trainer has the freedom then to make notes, to bring in new vocabulary in the chat.
And of course, at the end, maybe to flag up one or other mistake, especially if they're common.
Make the most of it.
And if you want to, if you're interested, try us out at 3EnglishExpertsConversation on our website.
And you can also write to us if you want to have a trial session, which we'd love to see you at and help you with your English.
Right.
Thanks, Dave, for this golden nugget.
And in our upcoming episode, we are bringing some more vocabulary to you.
The topic will be synonyms, so finding other words for maybe the most obvious or simpler words like walk.
Yeah, you could stroll.
That's just one idea, one example to level up.
And that's really something for an offer on a higher level to maybe on a B1 or B2.
You want to be on C1+, so maybe some advanced vocabulary.
But we want to offer people alternatives and give some ideas.
There are so many words probably we don't use very often, but there are a lot of words.
So let's take a look into that and help you upgrade your vocabulary, enlarge it.
And hopefully you will be pressing plate again and will be listening to us.
Thanks for listening today.
Bye bye for now.
Bye.
Bye.
Thank you so much for pressing late today.
If you enjoy our podcast, please share with your friends, your family or your co-workers.
Or you can also support us by giving us a thumbs up or a star rating or a review on whatever podcast platform you are using to listen to us.
For questions and comments, you can also head over to our website, 3EnglishExperts.com.
Thank you so much for listening.
We really appreciate your support.
Have a great day and see you next time.